FIELD NOTES — GIFTING NOTES
This guide may contain affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We only recommend the kinds of things we’d keep ourselves.
The Short List
Know your limit? Jump to it.
The white elephant is the only gift exchange where the goal is to bring something people will fight over.
Most of the table brings a candle and a mug. You bring the thing that gets stolen three times and frozen. Every pick here works for anyone who might open it, stays under the usual office limits, and comes with a steal rating so you know what you’re walking in with.
House rules vary. Check whether your office allows anything bar-related before you buy, and keep it work-friendly when in doubt.
Under $20
For the office that set the limit low and meant it.
Golf cart cigar holders, 3-pack
about $10- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Clips to the cart and keeps a cigar off the grass. Every golfer at the party will want them, and there are three to fight over.
- Steal odds
- Medium
- Why it works
- Screws onto the garage wall or the back porch post. The cheapest gift on the table and somehow the one people remember.
Bourbon barrel-aged maple syrup
about $20- Steal odds
- Very high
- Why it works
- Real maple syrup rested in bourbon barrels. Nobody expects to fight over syrup until they taste it.
Whiskey Nuts snack mix
about $13- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Sweet and salty, made for the bar. Opened before the party ends nine times out of ten.
The Cocktail Deck, 52 recipe cards
about $15- Steal odds
- Medium
- Why it works
- One classic drink per card. Pull one at random and that’s what you’re making tonight.
DIY whiskey infusion kit
about $16- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Jars, botanicals and instructions for flavoring your own bourbon. A project in a box, and a good story at the next party.
Spinning whiskey glasses, set of 2
about $20- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Set one down and it turns on its rounded base. They come boxed with ice ball molds, and everyone who picks one up will give it a spin.
Under $25
The sweet spot for most office swaps.
Rocks glass with a real .308 bullet
about $25- Steal odds
- Guaranteed
- Why it works
- Made in the USA with a real bullet fused into the glass. This is the one that gets stolen three times and frozen.
Bourbon Trek trivia game
about $25- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Bourbon trivia for the whole table. Turns the gift exchange into the after-party.
16-in-1 keychain multitool
about $23- Steal odds
- Medium
- Why it works
- Bottle opener, screwdrivers and a ruler on one key-sized tool. Useful to literally everyone in the room, which is the white elephant dream.
Whiskey tasting journal
about $10- Steal odds
- Medium
- Why it works
- Pages for rating every pour. Pair it with a bottle if your exchange allows it.
Under $50
For the exchange where people actually try.
Globe whiskey decanter set
about $50- Steal odds
- Guaranteed
- Why it works
- A glass globe with a ship inside, two glasses and two ice stones. It looks like it cost twice the limit, which is exactly why it disappears.
Grilling rub gift set, 4 jars
about $37- Steal odds
- High
- Why it works
- Four rubs for steak, chicken and pork. The person who grills will make sure they leave with it.
Hot sauce challenge, 10 bottles
about $45- Steal odds
- Very high
- Why it works
- Mild to truly unreasonable. Someone will try the last bottle at the party, and everyone will remember it.
How to win the white elephant
- Wrap it heavy and plain. A big, mysterious box gets picked early.
- Pick something that looks expensive for the price. Glass and wood always do.
- Choose a gift that’s fun to open in front of people. It sets the mood for the whole game.
- When it’s your turn to steal, go for the one that’s been stolen twice. It’s about to freeze.
THE SOCIETY’S GIFTING NOTES
Bring the one they’ll steal.
TIER 1
Under $20
The surprise favorite. Cheap, a little unexpected, and gone before the third round.
Our pick: the bourbon barrel-aged maple syrup
TIER 2
Under $25
The guaranteed steal. Nobody leaves without trying for it.
Our pick: the .308 bullet rocks glass
TIER 3
Under $50
The showpiece. It looks like it broke the limit, and it didn’t.
Our pick: the globe whiskey decanter set
Given with love: a white elephant is really about laughing together. Bring something you’d be glad to take home yourself, and cheer for whoever steals it.
